Back to Off Topic

Does God exist?

almost 10 years

I'm taking a survey for my Harvard PhD thesis.

Does God exist?
73
Yes
67
No
36
Not sure
deletedalmost 10 years

cezarus says

But that doesn't mean we can simply assume that this entity doesn't exist,


But, I just did.
almost 10 years
But that doesn't mean we can simply assume that this entity doesn't exist, hence to believe and be absolutely sure that God does not exist is essentially no different than claiming he exists without backing it up with any proof.
deletedalmost 10 years

cezarus says


RepubIic says


cezarus says

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Saying, "God doesn't exist" is ultimately as dogmatic as saying he does. We just don't have the means nor the ability to yet determine whether "God" exists. It's no different from saying extra-terrestrial beings don't exist because we haven't seen them yet.


Okay, so it's arrogant to think Unicorns and Dragons don't exist either, because we don't have evidence that they exist and don't have evidence that they DONT exist? good to know. HOGWARTS EXIST EVERYONE and if you think it doesnt you're just arrogant.


The difference in those instances are very clear, don't you think? Unicorns and dragons are beings that supposedly roam the Earth and thus can be observed directly which implies that their absence is sign that they do not exist. It's an entirely different thing when you talk about God. I'm not talking about the Christian God whose absence can very well be assumed for obvious reasons. No, what I'm talking about is God as this supreme entity that is above everything, above universe and unfortunately up till now we do not yet have the means and the ability to really determine whether this entity exists or not.


I understand what you're saying, but it does not mean choosing to not believe in a God is somehow arrogant for reasons being a lack of evidence.
almost 10 years

RepubIic says


cezarus says

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Saying, "God doesn't exist" is ultimately as dogmatic as saying he does. We just don't have the means nor the ability to yet determine whether "God" exists. It's no different from saying extra-terrestrial beings don't exist because we haven't seen them yet.


Okay, so it's arrogant to think Unicorns and Dragons don't exist either, because we don't have evidence that they exist and don't have evidence that they DONT exist? good to know. HOGWARTS EXIST EVERYONE and if you think it doesnt you're just arrogant.


The difference in those instances are very clear, don't you think? Unicorns and dragons are beings that supposedly roam the Earth and thus can be observed directly which implies that their absence is sign that they do not exist. It's an entirely different thing when you talk about God. I'm not talking about the Christian God whose absence can very well be assumed for obvious reasons. No, what I'm talking about is God as this supreme entity that is above everything, above universe and unfortunately up till now we do not yet have the means and the ability to really determine whether this entity exists or not.
deletedalmost 10 years
Unicorns and Dragons originate from the Bible FYI.
deletedalmost 10 years

TheVigil says


RepubIic says


cezarus says

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Saying, "God doesn't exist" is ultimately as dogmatic as saying he does. We just don't have the means nor the ability to yet determine whether "God" exists. It's no different from saying extra-terrestrial beings don't exist because we haven't seen them yet.


Okay, so it's arrogant to think Unicorns and Dragons don't exist either, because we don't have evidence that they exist and don't have evidence that they DONT exist? good to know. HOGWARTS EXIST EVERYONE and if you think it doesnt you're just arrogant.


That's different as those examples are proven to by made up or exaggerated versions


No, the difference is one version is a fantasy people take seriously, the other is a fantasy people don't take seriously.

To prove something exists, you must have evidence. If you do not have evidence, it is not arrogant to therefore conclude it does not exists.
almost 10 years

RepubIic says


cezarus says

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Saying, "God doesn't exist" is ultimately as dogmatic as saying he does. We just don't have the means nor the ability to yet determine whether "God" exists. It's no different from saying extra-terrestrial beings don't exist because we haven't seen them yet.


Okay, so it's arrogant to think Unicorns and Dragons don't exist either, because we don't have evidence that they exist and don't have evidence that they DONT exist? good to know. HOGWARTS EXIST EVERYONE and if you think it doesnt you're just arrogant.


That's different as those examples are proven to by made up or exaggerated versions
deletedalmost 10 years

cezarus says

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Saying, "God doesn't exist" is ultimately as dogmatic as saying he does. We just don't have the means nor the ability to yet determine whether "God" exists. It's no different from saying extra-terrestrial beings don't exist because we haven't seen them yet.


Okay, so it's arrogant to think Unicorns and Dragons don't exist either, because we don't have evidence that they exist and don't have evidence that they DONT exist? good to know. HOGWARTS EXIST EVERYONE and if you think it doesnt you're just arrogant.
deletedalmost 10 years
Basically, eveything that we can't see or physically/mentally undergo is an example of Schrodingers Cat (sorry for the sloppy writing). As long as we never reveal the truth, God can exist, and not exist, at the same time. If I had to choose yes or no, I would honestly say no, but I'm under the mindset that as long as there is no critical evidence either way, I believe both sides are valid and I choose to remain on the fence. I have my personal opinion, but I'm not about to rule anything out or pick a side until I see the hard evidence.
almost 10 years

cezarus says

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.


That is to say, if something doesn't exist you cannot prove it doesn't exist. This applies to virtually everything, which is why you can only be 99.9% certain of anything. We usually go with that 99.9%, though. We don't live our lives constantly questioning gravity and we don't masturbate under the presumption the disappointed souls of our ancestors are watching. I've always found it queer why religion is the exception.
almost 10 years
Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Saying, "God doesn't exist" is ultimately as dogmatic as saying he does. We just don't have the means nor the ability to yet determine whether "God" exists. It's no different from saying extra-terrestrial beings don't exist because we haven't seen them yet.
deletedalmost 10 years
You should have added an option for "Indifferent" - I honestly am not affected either way.
deletedalmost 10 years

RepubIic says


Fruity says

I am a child of God and someone who is willing to speak to the world about Creationism and defend Him. Is that a reasonable enough "version" for you?


Which God?


Normally if someone references "God" with a capital G then they're referring to the god in the Christian Greek scriptures...
almost 10 years

Nattatatalie says

I think it's sort of arrogant to suppose you know the answer.


I said this at the start but they still dragged out 10 pages of bs.
almost 10 years
God is infinite and therefore nothing created God...
almost 10 years

Nattatatalie says

I think it's sort of arrogant to suppose you know the answer.


She like to argue so I sent that btch to law school - PREACH
almost 10 years
lmao
almost 10 years
long answer: no, he does not.
short answer: no
almost 10 years
I think it's sort of arrogant to suppose you know the answer.
almost 10 years

oooooooooo says

God may not be a "holy" spirit, but what we call God is a powerful creature that we know nothing about thinking that he will solve our every problem. Worshipping God is the same as worshipping any other creature.


Actually we live in the Matrix. Death is how you wake up and exit the Matrix. IF you want to exit the Matrix, you must die.
deletedalmost 10 years
idk why i just thik it... lol
deletedalmost 10 years
mmm i tink god real
deletedalmost 10 years

Antidote says

Does God exist?





sometimes
almost 10 years
God may not be a "holy" spirit, but what we call God is a powerful creature that we know nothing about thinking that he will solve our every problem. Worshipping God is the same as worshipping any other creature.
almost 10 years
The only question now is WHO Created GOD and is there more than one???